Reply to "Florence Parent Files Constitutional Challenge to Alabama Supreme Court Opinion"

quote:

Originally posted by Nurturing Father:
Judge Ned Suttle hasn’t positively affected this father and his daughters’ life. In a child custody modification case initiated by the mother, Judge Suttle did not properly apply Alabama law to factual evidence presented his court. Overwhelming evidence proved our little girl was well-adjusted and thriving, and the mother was continuing on the course that previously resulted in a Tennessee court order for equal-shared custody. Judge Suttle was reversed by the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals for his deliberately wrong decision (Davis v Blackstock Ala Civ App 2007).

Judge Suttle modified custody to the mother with complete knowledge the Tennessee Appeals Court said equal custody is best because ...“This record contains abundant evidence [mother] has refused to adhere to the plain requirements of the parenting plan and that she has purposely and deliberately embarked on a course which, if not stopped, would eventually erode the relationship between [father] and [child]. (Davis vs. Davis, TN 2004)."

Judge Suttle agreed with the mother that our 4 year old daughter needed 35 hours per week in daycare instead being in the personal care of her father. A father the Tennessee trial judge called “loving and nurturing.” With Judge
Suttle’s absolute knowledge the mother unsuccessfully attempted the same reasoning only 15 months earlier in a Tennessee court saying, “Our 18 month-old needed spontaneity of daycare to prepare her for schooling.”

To date, a total 9 learned judges from Tennessee and Alabama with legal costs to father of $30,000 have reviewed specific facts and circumstances to our individual situation. 8 of those 9 judges have issued legal opinions that court ordered equal-physical custody is best based for our little girl. Only Judge Ned Suttle condoned the mother’s judicial forum shopping to limit the father-child relationship.

See legal documents to back up these factual statements at <www.whyjudgesuttle.com>

In my humble opinion retirement is exactly where Ned Suttle needs to be.

I am the father.
Mark Davis
Florence, Alabama