Thats great UW! Me and you would and will rock right along then. When the majority of believers start thinking and judging people as you do then the world will be much better.
Sadly we are in a minority.
Many christians when presented with that limited amount of information will automatically think the christian would have better morals than the atheist.
I think smart christians would also agree with us about keeping religion out of our laws, schools, etc. If they have thought about it realistically they do.