Skip to main content

This is in the news, so it's posted in the "news" section:

 

http://www.foxnews.com/health/...t/?intcmp=latestnews

 

When rescuers arrived to Missouri's Lake Sainte Louise on Jan. 19 after reports that three 14-year-old boys had fallen through the ice, John Smith had already been underwater for 15 minutes.

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports he was taken to a hospital with no pulse, and while his companions were treated for hypothermia, staff performed CPR on John for 27 minutes.

 

"He was dead for 45 minutes," Dr. Kent Sutterer tells KSDK. There was a "very poor chance of survival." But when the doctor called John's mom into the room, "she started praying loudly," he says.

 

Adds Joyce Smith, "I don't remember what all I said. But I remember, 'Holy God, please send your Holy Spirit to save my son.' ... All of a sudden I heard them saying, 'We got a pulse, we got a pulse.'" Today, John's brain function is normal and he's at home walking and talking like any other teenager, KSDK reports.

 

He's getting physical therapy to regain some movement in his hands, but otherwise he's only battling a cough. "After listening to what the paramedics and doctors said I'm pretty surprised at the outcome," John says.

 

Dr. Sutterer, who says John's heart started within "a minute or two" of his mom's prayers, later wrote a note to make sense of the experience.

 

"His heart was jump started by the Holy Spirit listening to the request of his praying mother," it reads. Another doctor adds that "it's a bona fide miracle."

 

John's rescuers from Lake St. Louis Fire and Emergency had practiced ice rescues just days before he was saved. (A 2-year-old recently survived a night outside in freezing temperatures.)

 

LIbEraliSm

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Timing is everything.

 

There have been numerous instances of revival of persons who "drowned" in icy water and were deemed "dead" by someone's criteria.  The rapidly-lowered body temperature induces a sort of dormant state that delays death and enables resuscitation.  That the kid's heart began beating concurrently with the mother's prayer does not prove that there was any divine intervention, notwithstanding the totally unscientific speculation by the attending doctors.  That old post hoc ergo propter hoc logical fallacy seems to have come into play here.

Originally Posted by Road Puppy:

Contendah's absolutely right.

Cold stasis is something us homies of the great white north are familiar with.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspended_animation

 

Prayer is just wishful thinking.  A way to do absolutely nothing and still think you're helping.


Your link has the following disclaimer:

"This article possibly contains unsourced predictions, speculative material, or accounts of events that might not occur."

Originally Posted by Mr. Hooberbloob:
Originally Posted by Road Puppy:

Contendah's absolutely right.

Cold stasis is something us homies of the great white north are familiar with.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspended_animation

 

Prayer is just wishful thinking.  A way to do absolutely nothing and still think you're helping.


Your link has the following disclaimer:

"This article possibly contains unsourced predictions, speculative material, or accounts of events that might not occur."

--------------

Are you really that dense?

 

Well, then-maybe you just aren't familiar with how extreme cold can affect the body.  If you've ever spent any time up north in the winter- you don't even need to be a doctor to observe the effects.

 

Here's a reference to a study NASA did published in 1973:

http://naca.larc.nasa.gov/sear...nt%2BType%7CReprint#

Here's another link:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/ru...in-wounded-patients/

 

And another:

http://www.newscientist.com/ar...ll=true#.U4OV6fldXu8

 

And yet another:

http://www.engadget.com/2014/0...ed-animation-trials/

 

Aaaaaannnnnnd another:

http://www.bbc.com/future/stor...he-dead-back-to-life

 

Annnnnnd yet another (shall I go on, you Luddite?):

http://science.howstuffworks.c...enetic/cryonics1.htm

 

An excerpt detailing what we New Englanders are familiar with because we see several instances of it a year:

 

"To understand the technology behind cryonics, think about the news stories you've heard of people who have fallen into an icy lake and have been submerged for up to an hour in the frigid water before being rescued. The ones who survived did so because the icy water put their body into a sort of suspended animation, slowing down their metabolism and brainfunction to the point where they needed almost no oxygen"

 

The human trials were held last year and docs have done this regularly for quite some time now to buy time to fix the damage.

 

Now you know.

Last edited by Road Puppy
Originally Posted by Mr. Hooberbloob:

Per your link: 

 

"This can give them up to 45 minutes in which to stop blood flow and perform surgery. However, the cooling process takes time and can only be done with careful planning and preparation."

 

I'm much more successful than you pup, if I'm dense, then you must be downright stooopid.

---------------

OK Einstein........

Now how much "careful planning and preparation' do ya suppose the people who fell through the ice underwent?

 Success *obviously* isn't a matter of intelligence.

 You can pick up your leaf blower on the way out, Sparky....

Last edited by Road Puppy
Originally Posted by Road Puppy:
Originally Posted by Mr. Hooberbloob:

Per your link: 

 

"This can give them up to 45 minutes in which to stop blood flow and perform surgery. However, the cooling process takes time and can only be done with careful planning and preparation."

 

I'm much more successful than you pup, if I'm dense, then you must be downright stooopid.

---------------

OK Einstein........

Now how much "careful planning and preparation' do ya suppose the people who fell through the ice underwent?

 Success *obviously* isn't a matter of intelligence.

 You can pick up your leaf blower on the way out, Sparky....

_______

People looking for miracles are going to "find" miracles, whether they are there or not.

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×