Skip to main content

Let the distraught partners of terminally ill who commit suicide die too, says Dignitas boss

By Daily Mail Reporter
Last updated at 8:28 AM on 19th October 2010


Dignitas clinic head Ludwig Minelli says relatives should be allowed to have prescriptions for suicide drugs even when they are not terminally ill

The founder of controversial Swiss clinic Dignitas has said a person whose terminally ill partner commits suicide should also be given help to die – even if they are perfectly healthy.

Ludwig Minelli wants the deadly drug that is prescribed to his clients to be made available to the partners of those suffering from dementia.

At present Swiss law states it is legal to assist only those with a terminal illness.

He said: ‘A change in the law is required to give dementia sufferers and their families more opportunities.

‘The partner should be allowed to have a prescription for these drugs even when they are not terminally ill.

In such cases the partners are often a similar age and one does not want to remain without the other.’

The human rights lawyer spoke following the case last week in Switzerland of a 64-year-old man who strangled his wife of 30 years who suffered from Alzheimer’s disease.

He described it as ‘an act of desperation’.

Zurich public prosecutor Andreas Brunner rejected Mr Minelli’s proposal to widen the legislation.

He said: ‘In my view, no change in the law should be sought.’


It is not the first time Mr Minelli has argued healthy people should be given the legal right to die.

Last year he said that he believed assisted suicide should be available ‘on demand’.

Mr Minelli, whose organisation has supervised the deaths of more than 100 Britons, said suicide was not just for those who were dying but ‘a marvellous possibility given to a human being’.

He has dismissed concerns that assisted suicide should be reserved for the terminally ill as a ‘British obsession’.

consider this warning Paul gave: "See then the kindness and the severity of God: severity toward those who have fallen, but God’s kindness to you, provided you continue in his kindness; otherwise you too will be cut off" (Rom. 11:22)

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I know euthanasia is controversial.
I am a big fan of Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, she was a Doctor and writer, and she wrote books on the subject of dying and the pain involved. She did not believe in assisted suicides, and stated that if we took better care of our dying, (medically and emotionally) we wouldn't have this issue.

whether you are for euthanasia or not. it's obvious that Ludwig Minelli is out to make money

This is also why grief therapy is so IMPORTANT! I speak from experience .....
as many of you also may understand in your own lives.
yet.... at the same time....

if some one is so totally through with life they are ready to hit the off switch, what gives *US* the right to tell them no?

what gives US the moral high ground that allows us the final word on what someone else may or may not do with their body?

i'm making no claim either way, about which is right... or which is wrong.

i'm merely asking... how do we justify making someone else continue living when they have clearly stated they choose death?

what makes us right, and them wrong?
quote:
Originally posted by thenagel:
yet.... at the same time....

if some one is so totally through with life they are ready to hit the off switch, what gives *US* the right to tell them no?

what gives US the moral high ground that allows us the final word on what someone else may or may not do with their body?

i'm making no claim either way, about which is right... or which is wrong.

i'm merely asking... how do we justify making someone else continue living when they have clearly stated they choose death?

what makes us right, and them wrong?



nagel,

In my opinion, one should say something to stop it. It's not a moral high ground but a final word
that might change their mind. It is wrong, self murder, They may thank you later.

I believe God would want you to make an attempt to at least do something. If they still choose death,
God knows you did what you could. You can always justify stopping a wrong.

Add Reply

Post

Untitled Document
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×