quote:
Originally posted by Not Shallow Not Slim:
However, we must draw certain conclusions from evidence. Try as we might, there is no evidence that dogs give birth to cats. We can say with certainty that it does not happen.
i realize this is a little old now, and that i have already responded to it, i think... but the more and more rum i drank, the more and more this idea made me giggle.
ok.. so lets run with this concept, shall we?
there is no evidence that dogs give birth to cats.
stipulated.
there is also no evidence that elephants explode when poked with a 3 tine fork. nor is there evidence that wombats fly backwards at night, on the 3rd tuesday of months with an " R " in them
and none of the above has the least bit to do with the existance, or the non esistance, of god.
it's misleading bupkis, trying to approximate something that is outlandish and untrue, with something that merely has no solid proof.
how many people laughed at Mr. Pasteur about the invisible goblins hs suggested, until people stopped getting sick as much, simply by the act of washing their hands more often?
he had no proof, just speculation. he saw a result, and took a guess at why, and proposed a soloution. and so now we have milk. i'm not sure about the details of this discovery.
well, i look at flowers.. and i look at bees.... and i think.. wow.. two vastly different things so intimately and essentally conected for no reason that presents itself acedemically.
and i take a guess at why, and i think of a soloution - because it was INTENDED to be that way.
( pease note: before you start, bees and flowers are the least of examples.... but i'm toasted and couldn't come up with anything moer complicated)
now... with that said: bees and flowers and their intereaction do NOT automatically indicated, for me, the existance of an all powerful creator, any more than a toy car indicates a 12 year old worker in a chinese plant, carving molds for tiny plastic wheels and prepping them for lead based paint.
i'll say this for you, tho i've said it before... and if b50m is right, you've already read it.
i don't believe in the God you are probably fighting against.
if the fundies likle TheBill are correct, i'm just as screwed as you are.
i believe in a God who created it all. you don't even have to call him god if you don't want. i used the word for a lack of anything else. call him Doug for all i care.
Doug came along, from where i know not. Doug saw a void, and he filled it. ( how, i know not)
Doug designed all that is and all that will ever be. Designed, mind you... not 'created' as in " POOF" and it was there. Doug worked in the extreme long term scale.
Doug set his plans and designs in motion... and watched as the energy cooled and coalesed into the planets, galaxies, etc etc that we have now.
and he waits.
or acctually, perhaps he doesn't. maybe he's off doing the same thing in another universe we cna only dream about in science fiction novels.
and in the mean time, we .. it.. us.. them.. everything.. evolves... piece by piece... until we finally meet Doug's grand design.
he looks in from time to time.
he DOES care when is happeneing to us.... we are the whole point of it all, after all....
but doug cannot interfere.. cannot stop things or change things, because if he does, it *might* alter the plan he set about in the begining.
call him doug. call him God. call him whatever you like. i believe in a creator, and i don't much care what his name tag says.
and eventually, we'll evolve... spiritually.. intellectually... emotionally... into what he planned from the begining.
all i have to base this on is one phrase. one line.
" this is how much i love you. i exist, but i am not as you have been told"
well... i was told that god watches every little step, sees the fall of every sparrow, guides our hearts and our desires.... etc etc.. all the things your typical 'christian' child is taught growing up.
well, when i hear ' i am not as you have been told' it pretty much blows all of the rest out of the water, doesn't it? so i have to think... what makes sense now... what cna be real, if everything i had been told is false?
what do i believe in, if the whole of the bible is a lie?
if He isn't watching over us, wtf is He doing?
and i realized.... his eye is on the sparrow. he marks the fall of every sparrow.
but he doesn't do anything about it, does he?
that didn't mean that he wasn't real... it meant what we thought about him was wrong.
anyway. that's where i am.
you hop up and down ranting that god is false.... and when we are discussing the Christian God, the God of the bible, i admit i believe you are probably correct. i don't believe in that god either - i don't certainly believe in bill grays god, or in the god of the old and new testament either.
but i am pretty certain, in my own heart and mind, there IS a force out there, a conciousness - one responsible for our origin.. the origin of the universe.. and i am equally certain he has a pretty straightforward but complicated and detailed plan that explains the reason for... all of this.
but i could be wrong.
what's the phrase? i read it in a book once.....
"while i might be mistaken, i am not uncertain".
it means i have no doubt, but i admit that i am merely human and don't know everything.